Direct-on-line (DOL) starting is the simplest and cheapest option, but it costs you in two places:
How a soft starter handles this: per Eaton's official technical article, a soft starter is a solid-state device that protects AC motors from damage caused by sudden power influx by limiting the large initial inrush current associated with motor startup. It provides a gentle ramp up to full speed and is used only at startup (and stop, if equipped), achieved by ramping up the voltage applied to the motor.
How it is implemented (per Eaton): most soft starters use thyristors or silicon controlled rectifiers (SCRs) in series to reduce voltage. The SCRs are engaged during ramp-up, and bypass contactors are pulled in after maximum speed is achieved, which significantly reduces motor heating. The formal name is RVSS — reduced voltage soft starter.
Do you need variable speed during the run phase?
Choose a VFD when:
Choose a soft starter when:
| Dimension | Soft starter | VFD |
|---|---|---|
| Speed control during run | Not available (after bypass, equivalent to DOL) | Available, continuous across the whole cycle |
| Starting current control | Voltage reduction / current limit (adjustable) | Current and torque controlled from near-zero speed |
| Rated torque at zero/low speed | No | Yes (with vector control) |
| Harmonics / power quality | Limited harmonics during start; negligible after bypass | Rectifier + inverter topology, usually needs line reactors/filters for harmonic mitigation |
| Energy savings | None (not in circuit during run) | Significant: Eaton states up to ~50% savings in US/Canada markets; under the affinity laws for fans, flow varies linearly with speed, pressure with the square, and power with the cube of speed |
| Footprint / cabinet space | More compact (especially at higher power) | Larger (especially at higher power) |
| Upfront cost | Lower | Eaton: typically 2-3× the cost of a soft starter |
| Life-cycle cost | Low upfront cost, no runtime energy benefit | Higher upfront cost, offset by savings on variable-speed duty |
Choose a soft starter if:
You must choose a VFD if:
Positioning: entry-level/compact, focused on small footprint and integrated bypass.
Critical status (per Schneider official datasheet): ATS48 is discontinued (Discontinued on: 2023-07-12), with the datasheet listing end-of-service on 2030-12-31. The official replacement range is Altistart 480 (ATS480). Spare-part sourcing, legacy replacement, and new projects should move to ATS480.
Verified representative model specifications:
| Model | Rated current | Power range | Voltage range |
|---|---|---|---|
| ATS48D17Q | 14.8 A | 3–15 kW | 230…415 V |
| ATS48C25Y | 240 A | 55–250 kW | 208…690 V |
In one line: built-in Modbus plus onboard thermal protection are its differentiators — but it is discontinued, so evaluate ATS480 directly for new projects.
Product structure (per Siemens official SIOS page): the 3RW5 generation has three tiers — 3RW50 (Basic) / 3RW52 (General Performance) / 3RW55 (High Performance; plus the 3RW55 Failsafe safety version). The previous generation is 3RW44 (high feature/performance).
Verified 3RW52 specifications:
In one line: widest power coverage (to 560 kW), the richest communication options (optional native PROFINET), and protection classes selectable for heavy-duty starting — suited to mid-to-large machines that must join an automation network.
| Item | ABB PSR | Schneider ATS48 | Siemens 3RW5 (3RW52) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Positioning | Compact entry-level (smallest footprint) | Heavy-duty industry and pumps (high-end) | 3RW50 Basic / 3RW52 General / 3RW55 High Performance & Failsafe |
| Status | Active | Discontinued (2023-07-12) → ATS480 | Active |
| Current coverage | 3.9–105 A | 14.8–240 A (verified model points) | 13–570 A |
| Power coverage | 1.5–55 kW @400 V | 3–250 kW (verified model points) | 5.5–560 kW @400 V |
| Built-in bypass | Built-in on all sizes | None built-in; external bypass optional | Hybrid switching technology (confirm per model) |
| Motor overload protection | Requires external thermal overload relay | Onboard (motor + starter thermal protection) | Onboard, selectable CLASS 10A/10E/20E |
| Communication | FieldBusPlug option (Profibus/Modbus/DeviceNet/CANopen) | Built-in Modbus | Optional PROFINET / PROFIBUS / EtherNet/IP / Modbus modules |
| Protection rating | IP20 | Not listed in datasheet (confirm in official manual) | IP20 / IP00; optional IP65 door-mounting kit |
| Best fit | Low power, tight cabinet space, cost-sensitive | Legacy ATS48 replacement (move to ATS480), pump duty | Mid-to-large power, lines that must join PROFINET and similar networks |
Step 1 — Determine the starting method
Step 2 — Set the duty class from the load type
Step 3 — Check starts per hour
Step 4 — Check bypass configuration and cabinet space
Step 5 — Check protection configuration (the most commonly missed item)
Step 6 — Check communication and integration
Step 7 — Check environment and derating
Step 8 — Check lifecycle and spares
The following are common issues observed on projects, not statistical conclusions.
Fradwell distributes the following soft starter brands with worldwide shipping and selection support:
Selection support: send us the motor nameplate (power, current, speed), load type, starting frequency, cabinet temperature, and whether network integration is required — we will come back with a comparison recommendation.
Soft starters and VFDs are not substitutes; they divide the work. A soft starter addresses starting current and mechanical shock; a VFD addresses runtime speed control and energy savings.
Three tests, in priority order:
By brand: for compact low-power duty look at ABB PSR (built-in bypass on all sizes); for pump duty and legacy replacement look at Schneider (ATS48 discontinued, move to ATS480); for mid-to-large power with PROFINET-class integration look at Siemens 3RW5.
Q1: Does a soft starter save energy? No. A soft starter works only during starting by reducing voltage to limit current; once maximum speed is reached the bypass contactor closes and the run phase is the same as DOL (per Eaton's official explanation). For energy savings, specify a VFD.
Q2: Which is better, a soft starter or a VFD? They serve different purposes. Variable speed during run, energy savings, or rated torque at zero speed → VFD. Fixed-speed duty where you only need to limit starting current and mechanical shock → soft starter (more compact, lower upfront cost). Per Eaton's official technical article, a VFD typically costs 2-3× more than a soft starter up front.
Q3: Does a soft starter need a bypass? Yes, but the form differs: ABB PSR has built-in bypass on all sizes; Schneider ATS48 has no built-in bypass, with external bypass available as an option. Built-in bypass saves a contactor and wiring in the cabinet; external bypass requires reserved space and budget.
Q4: Can I still buy a Schneider ATS48? ATS48 was discontinued on 2023-07-12 (official datasheet), replaced by Altistart 480 (ATS480). For legacy replacement, evaluate ATS480 specifications and any cabinet modification required; for new projects, specify ATS480 directly.
Q5: Does an ABB PSR need additional protection? Yes. The ABB PSR body has no electronic motor overload protection; the datasheet pairs it with external thermal overload relays (TF42/TF65/TF96/TF140DU), while short-circuit and overload protection is provided by a manual motor starter or gG fuses.
Q6: How do I select a soft starter for heavy-duty starting (conveyor/crusher)? Select by duty class, not by the motor's nominal power. Siemens 3RW52 offers trip classes per IEC 60947-4-2 — CLASS 10A/10E/20E (use 20E for heavy duty); Schneider ATS48 selections use utilization category AC-53A and heavy-duty power points. Also verify the starts-per-hour limit.
Q7: Are soft starters suitable for frequent starting? No. Soft starters have starting capability limits (e.g. ABB PSR: 4 × Ie / 6 s, with a starts-per-hour table in the datasheet). High-cycle starting, jogging, or precise position control calls for a VFD.
Shanghai Fradwell Industrial Automation Co., Ltd is a leading global supplier of high-performance industrial automation solutions, dedicated to connecting global buyers with high-quality Chinese automation solutions.
Siemens, Mitsubishi, Omron, Schneider, Delta, Xinje, Inovance, and other Chinese brands
WEINVIEW, Kinco, MCGS, industrial panel PCs
Inverters, servo drives, stepper systems, gear motors
Photoelectric switches, proximity switches, pressure sensors, temperature sensors, limit switches
Switching power supplies, solid-state relays, contactors, circuit breakers
Cylinders, solenoid valves, air treatment units
Website: https://www.industrial-automationcontrol.com/
Email: cnsales@fradwell.com
WhatsApp/WeChat: +8617717562982
Send us your BOM (Bill of Materials) – we will reply with a competitive quote within 24 hours!Our technical team is ready to assist. Contact us today for a free consultation!